Brandon Sanderson's Wheel of Time: A New Adaptation or a Grimdark Replacement?

As fans of The Wheel of Time, we're excited to see a new adaptation of this beloved series by Brandon Sanderson. However, it's essential to approach this project with caution and ensure that the tone and direction align with the original story. One aspect that concerns me is the decision to have Perrin kill his wife in the adaptation. While I understand the idea behind it, I think it's a grave mistake.

Firstly, killing off a main character's loved one can be seen as a cheap trick to add drama to the story. It feels like a trope often used in media, where the protagonist's significant other is sacrificed for plot convenience. Perrin's wife is an important character in her own right, and taking her away from him without proper exploration of their relationship would be detrimental to his character development.

Moreover, the trauma that Perrin would experience after killing his wife would be immense and difficult to deal with responsibly in an adventure series. It's a heavy burden for any character to carry, and I fear that it would overshadow other important aspects of the story. The writers would need to handle this plot point with care and sensitivity to avoid trivializing the issue.

Brandon Sanderson himself expressed disagreement with this change, stating that he prefers to keep Perrin's wife alive in his original work. He also mentioned that there was a line in one of the books where Perrin says he would have married Laila Dearn if he had stayed in the Two Rivers for a few more years, which is where the inspiration for the character came from.

Instead of relying on gratuitous violence and trauma, I believe it's essential to focus on Perrin's inner struggles and character growth. Showcasing his rage issues and fear of unleashing his inner beast would be a more compelling direction for his storyline. This approach would allow for a deeper exploration of his psyche and provide a more nuanced portrayal of his character.

In conclusion, while the idea of Perrin killing his wife might seem appealing at first glance, I think it's a mistake that could have far-reaching consequences for the story. It's crucial to stay true to the original work and avoid leaning into grimdark themes that detract from the essence of The Wheel of Time. By focusing on character development and responsible storytelling, we can ensure a successful adaptation that honors the spirit of Brandon Sanderson's work.

Brandon sanderson books by year